image: Johnny Vulkan“...the hourly clicking of Oxfords and high heels across the parking lot.”
You don’t choose the Staten Island Hotel—it, like death, chooses you. And the moment I glimpsed its dim, crusty yellow lights after five hours in my parents’ Camry on our emergency trip to New York 11 years ago, I knew that my family was next on the hotel’s hit list.
The Staten Island Hotel and its excessively convenient location to our upcoming funeral activities in Brooklyn and Elmont temporarily interrupted my 16-year-old life and that of my family just after my great-aunt’s heart failure permanently interrupted hers. But as a teenager, I didn’t care if I was in New York for a funeral. I just wanted to make the most of what I saw as one of my first voyages to the big city. That evening, my older brother and I talked for a while about sneaking into Manhattan and catching a taping of the Daily Show[1].
But our room’s yellow pages didn’t help us find Comedy Central’s studios[2]. Kept from the flashy New York I imagined, I had to look elsewhere for entertainment.
So across the hall in my parents’ room, I found what entertainment I could in watching my father as he sat at the desk, his suitcase still closed and all his papers with driving directions spread on the bed, as he called his colleagues from the room phone to ask them to cover his work for the next couple of days. It was then that someone decided we shouldn’t go hungry all night, and of all the restaurants in New York City, we opted for the hotel’s and its bland, runny pasta and shoddy service. During dinner, my aunt made the waitress switch the X-Files[3] off the dining room TV, halfway through an episode. The show was apparently too violent—or maybe too fun?—for my younger cousin.
Even though she got rid of the X-Files, my aunt couldn’t do away with the night’s real main attraction: the screaming below my room’s window and the hourly clicking of Oxfords and high heels across the parking lot. I now realize that the Staten Island Hotel chose those businessmen and their hookers just like it chose us.
At the funeral the next day, a relative I’d only seen twice in my life told me, “It was so good of you to come.” Later that night, I was relieved that I didn’t have to tell that relative, “Actually, I caught a show and had a great meal while I was here.” Instead, with comfort, without guilt, I could recall that all I did on my big night in town was to treat my hotel like the sleazy purgatory it was—and to have no fun whatsoever. That was my New York City.
commentary